There is a zealous appetite for more
stock offerings within regional markets as excess money supplies seek
investment opportunities. Speaking at the 2006 Funds Summit in Dubai, Mark
Mobius, the managing director of Franklin Templeton Asset Management in
Singapore, remarked that while that there have been several stock market
listings this year in the Middle East, there simply aren’t enough initial
public offerings (IPOs) coming into the market to keep prices realistic. He
added, "There was too much money chasing too few stocks. Even with the
corrections that stock markets have suffered this year, share prices in the
region remain high." For Mobius there is a simple solution to the current
situation, "You’ve got to have more IPOs."
For the most part, it seems he is right.
Despite a robust overall economic drive and positive corporate results,
regional stock markets experienced a near free-fall in the previous year and
hit two-year lows. Dubai was down 65 percent, Abu Dhabi by 41 percent and
Saudi Arabia, the biggest in the region, slid 48 percent. Yet, even with
corrections and underperformances within the markets, largely due to
liquidity-driven stretched valuations, stock prices still remain high.
Moreover, the fall in regional equity markets hasn’t prevented IPOs from doing
well.
In 2006, IPOs were expected to raise
more than $8 billion. Nine months into the year the raised figure reached
nearly $6.2 billion, meaning a 45 percent increase from the same period in
2005. According to private equity firm Persian Gulf Capital, IPOs in the
region were oversubscribed an average of 98 times in the first nine months of
2006. Meaning, those that had listed by end-September had appreciated an
average of 123 percent.1 During the first nine months of 2006,
demand for shares in IPOs in the region exceeded supply by 47 times on average
during the first nine months of 2006. One contributing factor is the leading
perception that primary markets provide quicker profit-making opportunities.
For example, Emaar Economic City’s IPO was oversubscribed by 2.8 times, as 10
million Saudis subscribed for 7.18 billion Saudi riyals ($1.95 billion) in
shares. This seemingly unstoppable yearning for IPOs is expected to remain in
the coming year and new issues are expected to be oversubscribed as well.
While some analysts have pointed out the
difficulty of completing the IPO process, which calls upon firms to adopt new
legal and business measures, others believe that we will be seeing more IPOs
floating in the future, even with depressed regional share markets. "If the
market remains at the current level, what you will probably see is a downward
revision in IPO valuations. But there is a large number of companies standing
in the queue [to float IPOs] and there will be a sufficient number willing to
come to the market," states Imad Ghandour, the head of research and strategy
of Persian Gulf Capital.
His firm also estimates that nearly 134
companies in the region will float IPOs over the next three years. However,
some companies have not been as enthusiastic about putting forth their IPOs
given the unstable equity markets. Oger Telecom cancelled its $1.25 billion
IPO hours before its opening and a number of Saudi IPOs were pulled out midway
through the process or were delayed. The fall in regional share markets,
bringing about depressed valuation, is also expected to slow down the
introduction of new IPOs.
Another factor slowing down the drive
for IPOs may be the poor performance of leading regional markets in 2006. In
terms of market performance, the year was the worst for the Saudi market,
which is the largest in the region and naturally affects all others. Losses
last year wiped out all the gains achieved by the market in 2005. Yet, Saudi
Arabia remains the most active IPO market, raising more than $2.3 billion in
the first nine months of 2006. The UAE and Qatar markets raised $1.4 billion
and $1.3 billion respectively, while the Bahraini IPO market was
uncharacteristically active, with $1 billion raised compared with only $6
million in 2005.
Certainly, the demand for IPOs will
remain high in the coming years as floating capital looks for viable
investment options. The supply of IPOs will likely be as forthcoming since
many companies realize the potential benefits of issuing IPOs and the
feasibility of raising funds through the process. The region is hungry for
more IPOs and it will be seen how that hunger can be satiated.